Thursday, December 07, 2006

A Little about Voice, Character, and the Plucking of a Bright Beginning from the Sea of Nothingness


And to Think, that Came Out of Me

"Characters take on life sometimes by luck, but I supect it is when you can write most entirely out of yourself, inside the skin, heart, mind and soul of a person who is not yourself, that a character becomes in his own right another human being on the page." __ Eudora Welty


Here's a blog about nothing. And everything. And how to -- hopefully -- start with the former and end up with the latter. It's all about beginnings, and voice, and creating that perfect character, and staying true to that voice and that character throughout the body of work, and ... .

But let's move forward, shall we?

I'm going to start by talking about beginnings. Again. Forgive me, but I love a great beginning. A good writer makes them seem so easy. And yet writing one is so very, very hard. A strong beginning is so important. It anchors the book, and ultimately sells it. First to an editor, then to the readers.

So let's take a look at the process. I'll use my own trial and error struggles as examples. Besides trying to nail voice and character, I am also trying to decide between first and third person, past or present tense for my WIP. Please bear with me.

Here's the first stab in the dark:

A strange foreboding of homesickness washes over me as I juggle to pull the front door of my apartment closed. I ignore the feeling. It makes no sense -- I'll be back home in a couple hours.

Let me introduce myself. My name's Dianne Harris and I'm twenty four. Since my husband died in a car crash 16 months ago, and I became a single mother, I'm juggling more than just what I'm carrying ... .

Yawn. No voice here to speak of. Dry and booorrring.

Let's try again:

From the moment my pregnancy test stick turned blue, my goal was to give my baby something I didn't have growing up -- parents. Real parents -- a biological mother and father living under the same roof. I thought that's what I was giving her when I married Matt. But the accident snatched away my dream before it got started. Matt didn't even get a chance to lay a hand on my stomach and feel Megan kick and roll inside. He lived and drove too fast, and died behind the wheel of his beefed up 1970 Chevelle when I was only two months pregnant.

Better. A little more voice. But no hint of the supernatural elements yet to come, and sort of whiny. Still not what I'm hoping for.

Okay, take a deep breath, relax, and give 'er another shot:

Dianne Harris woke on a drizzly Saturday morning in November, not knowing her life was soon to change forever. She greeted the day with smiles for her three-month-old baby girl, and adjusted to the grieving acceptance settling like lava rock in the pit of her stomach. Neither her inner discomfort, nor the gray pallor of the Oregon coastal sky felt like a premonition of things to come. Dianne didn't believe in supernatural feelings. She was well-grounded in reality and firmly rooted in her life as a young, widowed mother, so she casually shoved the blunt edges of sleep and uneasiness to the dark recesses of her subconscious and went about her day.

This is okay. But a little too slow for the story I want to tell. And in third person, past tense, feels too stiff and formal -- too literary-ish. (Not that there's anything wrong with writing literary-ish. It's just not my intention with this story).

Can you say try again?

This time I want something new, different, exciting. I'll turn my own voice off, and write from some chasm deep within. Uh-huh, yeah. That's just what I'll do:

When I open my eyes it's drizzling outside. Little tip taps of raindrops hit my roof, like they do every November. But this morning, something don't seem right about it. Like something big and changing about to happen, something I can't do nothin' to stop. I feels my body. Runs my hands all over myself. I'm jus' the same. A little too big through the hips, a little poochie in the tummy area. Woman's always got a poochie tummy after she give birf though. You'd be poochie too, girl, you gots a baby only three months old.

Okay. Wow. Where did that come from? It does have a little Eudora Welty flavor going on there. (Lord, please forgive me for being so egotistical as to compare my writing-- even a single paragraph -- to Eudora Welty's).

Now this voice I like. It's unique, interesting. I don't know for sure how I got it, though, and I'm afraid I couldn't sustain it for a whole book. But it's a snippet I'll transfer to another file, and play with another day -- a fun short story voice, full of southern possibilities.

I'm getting closer.

You go, girl! Hit it again:

The only supernatural thing about Roseland, Oregon, is the crazy lady on Center Street who claims she can predict the future. So, when I whip into a parking space at the convenience store, almost hit a black dog roughly the size of Idaho, and its eyes glow red as it looks at me, I say to myself, "Ridiculous, Dianne. You must be seeing things." When the huge dog disappears into the mist, I say, "Good riddance," unload Megan from her car seat, try to forget about the dog, and go on inside the Coast Town Speedy Mart. I need a Diet Coke to lubricate my courage; my next stop is the newspaper office to drop off Grandma Austin's obituary. Facing her death, in black and white print, scares me more than I'd like to admit. So, basically, I'm procrastinating.

Inside the market, in front of the soda machine, I'm jiggling baby Megan up and down to keep her happy when I smell Kevin -- that same clean, fresh aftershave he's always worn. The scent of spice and forest and gentle breezes rustling through clothes hung on a line floods my memory, whisking me back to simpler days. Which, at the time, didn't seem simple at all.

This I can live with. Sentences tend to run on the long side, but I kind of like it anyway. Sets up the story, tone, place, supernatural elements, and the romance. Even gives a scene goal.

Of course, who knows how many more tweaks this will get before I'm done ... .


How many times do you rewrite your beginnings? Do you ever write something, look at it later and think, "Wow! That came out of me? Cool." How do you get yourself into the zone to do that? I can only write really inspired things in the morning. Afternoons I can edit and dink here and there, but my real creativity is shot by then. How about you?

22 comments:

Danita Cahill said...

Thanks, everyone, for putting up with this whole hook thing yet again.

And a special thanks to Paty for helping me see to start the final beginning where I did, and to Wavybrains who helped improve the hook itself.

You ladies are all the greatest!

And please feel free to share your own WIP hooks. That would be fun.

Alice Sharpe said...

Danita, I enjoyed reading about your process of finding your beginning. As I am now in that exact spot, the pressure of this issue is very fresh on my mind.

The more I write, the harder this gets. I've heard other writers say this as well. Another friend says writing is one of the few jobs she can think of that gets harder the longer you do it. I agree wholeheartedly and am relieved to hope it's not just me.

As you said, the beginning is not just about a hook. It's finding the right voice, it's the discovery of the moment the story truly starts independent of backstory, etc. It's how much to reveal, in what way to reveal it. And it is the hook, that intangible mysterious something that causes a reader's breath to catch.

Some book beginnings just come to me. I know the heroine is going to wake up with amnesia, dressed in rags with no identity, no clues as to who she is. Or I know a man is going to be waiting for a small plane to land before the snow hits in force, knowing it's going to bring trouble, determined to turn it away. I love those beginnings because they just came and though I tweaked them endlessly, their basic structure stayed the same.

The book I am writing now is different. Though I know the story, I don't know at what moment to start. What point of time? Whose point of view? How much does she know, how much does she suspect? What about him? Maybe he should start the book, maybe he should have thoughts about her before she has them about him. Maybe the bad guy needs to make a walk through, maybe not. Maybe her career choice--pivotal to this book and as of yet undetermined--needs to be the focus. And on and on.

I love these blogs, they alway get me thinking. Thanks, Danita, and I like your new starting point. You were right to keep pushing.

Alice

Anonymous said...

Danita, I like your last one best. It sounds like you. I can see you saying those things, and isn't that what you want? Your voice should sound like you, it's what makes you unique. The southern one - while good - wasn't you, and I stumbled through it, thinking, what the heck happened to Danita? LOL. Of course, that's because I know you - readers might not think the same.

Argh. Beginnings. There are certain books where openings just come to me. The proposal I just finished was like that. An idea hit and I went with it. I ended up rewriting the beginning once because my CP pointed out a more action-packed place to start, going back mere minutes in the story, but she was right. It's a much better opening hook. The opening itself stayed the same - same scenario, situation, just a slightly different start.

The proposal I'm working on now (GAH!!!), yes, same one from the beach, is a completely different story. I'm on my 4th opening, and not just opening hook, we're talking fourth STARTING point. I've tried a variety of different scenarios, and though all were good, they weren't "great" and that's been bugging me. I've changed location, time, and situation. I think I've finally found one that will work. Lots of intrigue - What's a cop doing breaking and entering into a house she already owns? - and conflict. So time will tell if this one works. I'm in the middle of chapter one now, and hope to get a lot done this weekend. Wish me luck.

Great post - and like Alice, timely for me. I appreciate you going over beginnings again!

Elisabeth Naughton said...

ARGH. Okay, that was weird. I signed it, yet it posted me as anonymous. How could I ever be anonymous????

Eli

Alice Sharpe said...

Eli--Your new beginning sounds very intriguing. I'm mulling it over to see how it can inspire me--or maybe I'll just steal it! As Danita says, Ha! Not really, but I like it a lot. Maybe my heroine could be face up in the mud staring at the underbelly of a horse positive she's just lost the job that would get her close to the evil drug lord---

Ack!

Alice

chanceofbooks said...

Kudos to you for saving all your different beginnings. When I erase something, it's gone to the ether for good.

The opening lines are often what comes to me first--the little snipet of an idea. However, in my current WIP, those lines turned out to open chapter three instead. Current opening is "You don't pick up chicks at a funeral"--and I got that opening in the outline stage.

With the YA that I just finished, I was married to the same hook from the very first idea. : "I dream in sugar." But recently, I started questioning the hook and the opening scene. (Thanks Danita, Becky, Jen for putting up with me)--still not completely sure how that will end up resolving itself.

With my first MS, I didn't know anything about hooks/beginings. The prologue opens "Hey, Constantly Annoying," and Chapter one also opens with Dialogue, "Hey, Dad? Dad? Are you listening to me?" Both lines came to me before I started drafting.

chanceofbooks said...

Oooh I like the new starting place Eli. That would keep me reading for sure.

Danita Cahill said...

Thanks, Alice,
As I've said before, compliments from you are cherished.

I hate hearing writing, and beginnings, get harder with time, because, dang, it's all hard enough right now!

So as you go through the struggle/decision making process about your beginning do you write out all the different opening scenes to see which works best for the story? Do you seek outside help? Or are you able to just keep pushing on through pages, and worry about it later? I would think that would make a lot of rewrites for later, though. For me, rewrites are my learning curve, for you it would seem like a horrible frustration, because your learning curve is much more experienced than mine.

Danita Cahill said...

Dear anonymous,

I'm so glad you posted. Just am not sure who the heck you are! (I think I know, but won't mention your name, in case you don't want others to know...)

Anway, that said: so glad that beginnings is not a subject I've run into the ground. I was concerned about that. It's been much on my mind too as I've struggled through to get it "right".

You'll find your right beginning too. In time. With work.

Sheesh.

No one ever said it was gonna be easy, though did they?

Danita Cahill said...

How funny, Eli!

I'm answering these one at a time, so didn't know it was you. (Didn't even think it was you, because your name and smilin' face always comes up) Thought it was someone else, but won't mention any names, since SHE may truly want to be anonymous. Ha!

Danita Cahill said...

Okay, is it just me, or are these dang work verification things we have to decipher and type in getting longer and harder to read these days?

Danita Cahill said...

If she was face up in the mud, Alice, staring at the underbelly of a horse, she would be noting if the horse was a stallion, gelding or mare. And if a male, if it needed it's sheath cleaned. Well, maybe that's something my heroine would notice, not yours, although if yous is a horsewoman...

Is it a calm horse, or is it prancing and jigging and ready to step on her. If it's calm, what's she doing lying under it?

Definitely some story questions presented with this hook. Especially the sheath-cleaning issue. Ha!

Danita Cahill said...

Wavy,
keep tweaking. You'll get it. Just think action.

On the pro loop, an editor just listed some of the common mistakes she sees that makes her reject manuscrpts. Slow beginnings was number one. Opening with dialog was another. It was a clever trick that was in vogue for a short time, she said, but she doesn't like anymore. Of course, she is just one editor. And she did point out, what sets her teeth on edge, may not bother someone else.

A slow beginning, though, doesn't work for anything anymore, I don't think, except literary works. And then it has to be beautifully done, like in "A Thousand Acres" that Eric Witchy read to us at a meeting.

Just my two bits.

Danita Cahill said...

Wavy,
forgot to say that in my stories, I write happily along at first, with back story etc...just to get it down. When I go back to figure out the true beginning, it is always further along in the story than it originally started. Sometimes three chapters in, like yours.

I dont look at it as a waste of time though, because if I know the character's history, it should help me write a better story. Right?

Alice Sharpe said...

Danita,
First off, it isn't just you. Those little wavy letters drive me nuts! Why do they have to be so darn hard to read and why so long????

You said: "So as you go through the struggle/decision making process about your beginning do you write out all the different opening scenes to see which works best for the story?

Sometimes, but not all the time. I work in my head nowadays, discarding ideas until something seems promising then trying it out for a few sentences, sometimes a few pages.

"Do you seek outside help? Or are you able to just keep pushing on through pages, and worry about it later? "

I sometimes do seek outside help. I have a friend in Denver who writes Intrigues and makes me laugh--you know her Karen, it's Kay--and she tried to help me this time. I believe she came up with the horse. I won't start until I know, however. I can't worry about it later because it's so important to be at the right place and time from the get go, just as you've said. I hardly ever rewrite more than a few words of a beginning--maybe I shouldn't admit that, but by the time I'm in chapter two, chapter one is pretty well as it will be except for that tweaking, cleaning up, embellishing stuff.

I don't know about my learning curve. I'll grant you the experience part, though, and I am sorry that you have to hear that it actually gets more difficult. But that's me and that's because for years I just took off running and seldom looked back and it just sort of worked. Now I'm putting the energy into it I should have from the start and which it seems you do that now so maybe it won't be harder for you (though I have a sneaky suspicion it might be. If we didn't push and grow, what would be the point?)

No sheath, gag. She'll be a mare. I tried it out in a few sentences and I'm afraid it just squatted there like a bloated frog. Sigh...

Alice who envies you and Eli and Wavybrains who at least have their starts. Right Eli? Did your new start hold up?

Karen Duvall said...

A really thought-provoking blog post, Danita. I always agonize over my beginnings. And they rarely ever stay the way I first write them. The only one that has is Desert Guardian, which begins: What a perfect night for a kidnapping.

Sometimes I can't decide at first who's POV I'm going to start the story with. So that has me shifting beginnings all the time. But I actually enjoy the challenge of working out the hook. I can feel it getting stronger as I revise, and that's very cool.

I like the whole "in media res" way of starting a story. So Danita, I really like the last opening hook you came up with. But I also liked the first one quite a bit. It was kind of "stream of consciousness" and raised a lot of questions. It introduced the viewpoint character nicely, and though you say there wasn't much voice there, I sure as heck saw it.

And what in the world is cleaning a sheath? I'm not liking what my imagination is coming up with. Please say it isn't so.

Wavy, I've practiced beginnings using dialogue and it always feels too rough, like readers will be walking in on a conversation in progress, which in real life is pretty disconcerting.

Alice, I'm so glad you and Kay met! She's definitely one of my all time favorite people and an excellent Story Magic partner. I can totally see her coming up with that beginning of waking up underneath a horse.

Eeeks! I have more to say but the clock is telling me I better run to my meeting or I'll be late...

Karen

Danita Cahill said...

Alice,
I envy you the working things out mostly in your head. Wish my head would do that.

And yeah, better make it a mare. My mare threw me one time. The moment I left her back, she stopped, put her head down, sniffed me and gave me a funny what-are-you-doing-down-there-dummy look.

God bless the equine.

Danita Cahill said...

Karen, you said:

I like the whole "in media res" way of starting a story. So Danita, I really like the last opening hook you came up with. But I also liked the first one quite a bit. It was kind of "stream of consciousness" and raised a lot of questions. It introduced the viewpoint character nicely, and though you say there wasn't much voice there, I sure as heck saw it.

What is "in media res". Did I do that?

As for the first hook I wrote, I'm going to go have another look at that now to see why you liked it.

Sorry about the meeting. We would have enjoyed more chatting with you!

And yes, your imagination is right on the sheath cleaning. If the owner doesn't do it periodically, a vet has to. An unclean sheath -- very painful to a horse. Sorry. Too much information, I know.

Karen Duvall said...

Well, I suppose if there's a shaft, there must be a sheath... oh, dear. Human males are pretty fortunate, considering.

"In media res" means in the middle of the action. So in your first beginning, you have Dianne in action, pulling open the front door to her apartment. And you leave the reader hanging (in a good way) as to where this feeling of homesickness comes from. We've all been homesick, it's a horrible feeling and we can relate to anyone who goes through it, so we want to know what's causing it for Dianne and will continue reading until we find out. We expect you to deliver the answer. 8^)

Speaking of writing, I'm hoping to do some of that this weekend. I've decided to forego the whole Christmas decorating thing and to leave the tree and trimmings up in the attic. I'll have no company this year since my grandson won't be here for Christmas, and we have two young kitties who'd be more than happy to make playful use of the holiday decor. No thanks. There's plenty of holiday glitz and glitter in town to more than make up for my paltry collection of baubles. 8^)

Karen

Danita Cahill said...

Thanks for explaining that, Karen.

I like your hook for desert guardian a lot.

Good luck with your writing this weekend, although it seems a little sad not to decorate for Christmas...
We did lights last weekend. Will put up our tree Sunday. Rick's big into Christmas, though, and we are having family over Christmas Eve.

I'm on page 152 of my WIP. I'm afraid I may not get too many more pages for the next week or so, what with the holiday shopping, wrapping, baking, parties, socializing, etc... but I still plan to try to crank out some, if only half a page, each morning.

One year I had two kittens at Christmas. They climbed the tree and knocked it over twice. Onaments shattered and/or rolling all over. Now that I think about it, you not decorating isn't so sad as it is smart...Ha!

Elisabeth Naughton said...

When I answer comments one at a time, Lisa accuses me of inflating my comment numbers because, as she puts it - it IS a competition. ROFL. (I think you win, Danita).

Okay, I just have to ask...what freaky horse farm do you live on? I grew up with horses - we had at least 3-4 - always. And I don't EVER remember my father (the horse man) cleaning our male horses sheaths. Ew. I get the willies just thinking about it.

I did watch two horses breeding once when I was young. Talk about leaving a lasting impression. It's an image I will never forget.

Danita Cahill said...

Eli,
I didn't know it was a competition. But I'm glad to know I might be winning anyway! (Lisa has never said anything to me about "inflating" my comment count. I haven't seen Lisa around the blog sight much at all lately....)

As for the horse sheath deal -- if you really want to keep talking about it...well, okay.

When I was a kid and had horses, we never cleaned a single sheath. It was only when my I bought my daughter a horse when she turned 9, and the vet came out to float (file his teeth -- yes, another nasty necessity) give him shots, etc...that I learned about the sheath- cleaning deal.

I'm not making this up.

When my daughter joined 4-H, and we started hanging around several professional stables the sheath cleaning (teat cleaning for mares) issue popped up again and again. It seems oil from the skin forms little granules, which, if not cleaned off, can grow to the size of peas, or bigger, and cause a lot of pain. The more you exercise a horse, the more the granules tend to just drop off on their own.

As for horses breeding -- yes. It is quite impressive. When I was a kid, I rode my horse to a neighbor girls (4 miles away) and spent the night. We tied our horses to a picnic table overnight. Stupid, but we were kids. My mare broke the table, got loose and got in with the stallion between my house and my friend's. I was raised on a farm, I knew the facts of life at an early age. A baby horse sounded really cool, so I took my mare back to the stallion the next day and held her while he got busy. I didn't tell my parents until 9 or 10 months later, when I started dropping little hints: "Wouldn't it be cook if Ginny had a baby?"

"Oh, honey, it takes a mommy horse and a daddy horse..." they gently explained.

Ha!

Ginny had a beautiful black filly. I trained her. To this day, my parents don't believe Ginny broke loose and got in with the stud on her own.

But, she really did. Honest.